Defiant City Council authorizes three-year review of city finances in response to CFO resignation

Posted

Mayor Brandon Johnson’s administration has characterized the internal dispute that triggered the resignation of Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch as a “technical difference of interpretation” and “much ado about nothing.”

The Chicago City Council strongly disagrees.

That much was obvious Wednesday when a veto-proof City Council majority voted 45 to 5 to authorize an independent review of the city’s finances and financial statements to reassure Wall Street rating agencies and would-be investors shaken by the abrupt departure of Johnson’s third CFO in the last year.

It was the latest and perhaps the strongest show of force yet by a City Council that has grown more independent than ever as it capitalizes on what they see as Johnson’s political weakness.

Budget Committee Chair Jason Ervin (28th), Johnson’s most powerful Council ally, denounced the three-year review as a “waste of taxpayers’ money” and a “waste of resources.”

“We’re talking theater here. I’m trying to figure out who’s gonna get the Emmy here and who’s gonna get the Oscar,” Ervin said.

“We might be a couple million dollars short because we decided to do something we already know the answer to.”

Ald. Jason Ervin (28th).

Ald. Jason Ervin (28th) speaking to the City Council earlier in November.

Anthony Vazquez/Sun-Times

Retiring Ald. Matt O’Shea (19th) countered there is a “clear lack of transparency, accountability and confidence” in the Johnson administration after Chicago’s third chief financial officer in a year “walked out the door.”

“We need an independent review of who knew, when they knew and what they did and what they were foolish enough to put in emails or in the presence of other people about our finances,” O’Shea said.

“People are looking at us. The taxpayers, bond rating agencies. They want to know what’s going on. And we owe it to the taxpayers to lift up the hood and see what’s going on and who knew what, what they knew about it and what they did about it.”

His voice rising, O’Shea said Chicago has an acting budget director, an acting CFO and an acting corporation counsel.

“That doesn’t show stability. That shows a clown car without anybody at the driver’s wheel,” O’Shea said.

“And if you’re not concerned about the that and just as important, if you’re not concerned about the way this administration repeatedly treats women in this building in leadership roles, then you’ve got a problem.”

Ald. Matt O'Shea (19th)

Ald. Matt O’Shea (19th) at a Chicago City Council meeting in September.

Ashlee Rezin/Sun-Times

The ordinance authorizes Finance Committee Chair Pat Dowell (3rd) to select and engage one or more independent professional services firms to conduct an “impartial and comprehensive review” to determine whether any “material or intentional misstatements of the city’s financial condition” have been made to investors, City Council and the public in any “document, presentation, offering or financial reporting within the last three years.”

Designated firms have subpoena power. City officials and employees are compelled to cooperate with the three-year investigation and provide access to all city records, reports and information requested by the designated firms, the ordinance states. Anyone who refuses to cooperate faces “employment sanctions, including suspension or discharge.”

Four years ago, Dowell broke with then-Mayor Lori Lightfoot and endorsed Johnson in what turned out to be a turning point in the 2023 mayoral campaign.

Johnson rewarded her with the Finance Committee chair, but history has repeated itself. Last year, Dowell led the budget rebellion that prompted the Council to reject Johnson’s corporate head tax. This year, she joined 27 colleagues in opposing more than $400 million of Johnson’s tax-the-rich ideas.

Wednesday’s vote was an equally important political break. The money to bankroll the financial review will be drawn from the Finance Committee’s annual budget, Dowell said.

Dowell described her support for the three-year review a "moment of angst" for her personally that "many of us share."

"Now more than ever, there are increasing eyes on the city's fiscal condition. They are all watching and we need to make sure that our math is correct," Dowell told her colleagues.

Pointing to what she called, “piecemeal emails and claims” that Gabrysch “missed meetings” and was “iced out,” Dowell said: “Where there’s smoke, there’s fire. The City Council must know the unvarnished truth.”

A former analyst for Fitch Ratings, Gabrysch resigned Friday after just three months on the job. She quit after being admonished, frozen out, and as sources closes to her said, bullied for publicly and privately contradicting the mayor’s claim that his $17.6 billion budget was 76% structurally balanced.

Gabrysch said only 56% of the moves the mayor had made to erase a $882 million shortfall were structural, because settlements tied to allegations of police abuse — and the $480 million in borrowing Johnson ordered to cover those costs — should not count as structural solutions.

At a City Hall news conference earlier this week, Johnson downplayed the conflict as a “technical” disagreement resolved by “providing both scenarios” in what he called the “spirit of full transparency.”

Acting Chief Financial Officer Michael Belsky called the disagreement “much ado about nothing,” even after Gabrysch concluded that “to continue in this role would be to compromise my integrity and professional obligation.”

Belsky instead argued that since the city “can issue bonds every year at any time to meet an obligation like settlements and judgments,” it is fair to say “that’s a structural match.”