Houston electric bills: Half of what you pay now goes to CenterPoint

Posted

Texans are frustrated by rising electricity bills — and some say they are struggling to keep up.

“When we moved in in 2019, my bill was never over $200,” Sean Gambini said. “Now the bill is $500, $600, $700 — almost $800.”

Dan and Irene Phillips said their electric bill has nearly doubled. Javier Alvarez said he feels powerless to change what he owes.

The increase is prompting questions about how Texas’ electricity market works, what deregulation changed and whether lawmakers can make the system more affordable.

Texas’ electric bills have risen nearly 40% over the past five years.

But deregulation is only part of the story. The amount customers pay includes both the cost of electricity and charges to deliver it, and those delivery fees have grown significantly.

What changed when Texas deregulated electricity?

In 1999, the Texas Legislature passed Senate Bill 7, beginning a restructuring of the state’s electricity industry. George W. Bush was governor, and Democrats controlled the Texas House. The legislation passed with support across party lines.

The plan was to introduce competition and lower the price customers paid for electricity.

Instead of one company generating power, delivering it and billing customers, the industry was divided into three roles:

  • Power generation companies produce electricity.
  • Retail electric providers buy electricity and sell plans to customers.
  • Transmission and distribution utilities, or TDUs, maintain poles, wires and meters and deliver electricity to homes and businesses.

Houston Lighting & Power was divided among three successor companies. Texas Genco took over power generation, Reliant Energy became a retail provider, and CenterPoint Energy took over the local transmission and distribution system.

Customers in deregulated areas can choose a retail electric provider. But about 15% of Texans live in areas that did not enter the competitive market and do not choose their provider. Some are served by electric cooperatives, which are owned by the people they serve. Others, including customers in Austin and San Antonio, are served by municipally owned utilities.

Are bills lower in cities that did not deregulate?

Average monthly bills in 2024=

  • Austin’s average was $104.85
  • San Antonio’s was $133.09
  • The average for other deregulated Texas cities was $166.19

(According to U.S. Energy Information Administration data.)

Before deregulation took effect, in 1996, the cost of 1,000 kilowatt-hours was $59 in San Antonio, $65 in Austin and $80 in Houston, the figures cited in the report show.

Those figures cover different measures — a price for 1,000 kilowatt-hours in 1996 and average monthly bills in 2024 — so they should not be read as a direct, like-for-like comparison.

RELATED: CenterPoint rates, profits and power outages: What Houston-area customers are paying for

Still, the 2024 numbers show that average bills in the deregulated areas cited were higher than those in Austin and San Antonio.

Barry Smitherman, who served on the Public Utility Commission of Texas when the market was first deregulated, said competition has kept electricity prices down.

“Absolutely. If you go to the Power to Choose website, you can find really inexpensive offerings,” Smitherman said.

He said the price of power was about 10.5 cents per kilowatt-hour before deregulation and has not changed in the 27 years since.

What has changed, he said, is the delivery fee — and how often it increases.

Delivery charges take a bigger share of bills

In many cases, customers pay CenterPoint as much or more to deliver electricity as they pay for the electricity itself.

One October bill reviewed for this report totaled $178.87. It listed $89.45 for electricity from the retail provider and $88.87 for CenterPoint’s delivery charge.

Houston’s Administration and Regulatory Affairs department says the delivery fee represented about one-quarter of a customer’s bill in 2003. It now accounts for about half.

Bill Kelly, who served as Houston’s director of government relations for eight years, said he reviewed CenterPoint’s proposed rate increases line by line with city officials and consultants.

“For every $3 that CenterPoint asked for, they would get two,” Kelly said. Between 2015 and 2019, he said, CenterPoint recovered $158 million, while the city’s review saved ratepayers $80 million.

Kelly said changes made by state lawmakers in 2023 weakened that review process. The changes allowed TDUs to raise rates twice a year to recover capital-improvement costs more quickly and shortened the review period for proposed increases from six months to 60 days.

“Instead of being able to go line by line and accountability with it on a full discovery process, the city now has an up-or-down vote,” Kelly said.

A look at Texas Deregulation and impact on Houston customers.

Houston City Attorney Arturo Michel said the city reviews a utility’s proposed costs and can agree with them or object. If the city objects, the matter goes to the PUC for litigation.

Michel said the city sometimes agrees with proposed increases because it believes the PUC would find them fair, or because it expects the commission to side with the utility.

Who reviews CenterPoint’s rates?

CenterPoint asked for 10 rate increases in 2025, and the PUC approved nine. Those approvals gave CenterPoint $5.1 billion.

CenterPoint reported $1 billion in profit that year, according its SEC filing.

“If you don’t regulate the monopoly, the monopoly will serve its own interest,” Kelly said. He said shareholders are being rewarded while ratepayers are being taken advantage of.

CenterPoint declined an interview request. A spokesperson said the company’s rates are approved by the PUC and that electric bills include both delivery charges and charges for electricity from the customer’s retail provider.

The PUC said rate cases receive extensive review and challenge, with multiple parties submitting hundreds of questions about a company’s costs, revenues and investments. But those major rate cases do not happen every year. CenterPoint’s last rate case was filed in 2024, and its next is expected in March 2029, according to the PUC. The 10 rate increases in 2025 were not part of a major rate case.

Can Texas undo deregulation?

Sandra Haverlah, president of the Texas Consumer Association, compared reversing deregulation to putting toothpaste back in the tube. She said it may not be feasible in areas already served by the competitive market, but lawmakers could change how the system works.

Kelly said lawmakers should restore a full discovery process so local officials can examine proposed rate increases line by line.

Haverlah urged customers to contact their state representatives and senators. “Participation in the process helps a great deal,” she said. “And it helps more than you think it does.”

Find your Texas lawmakers: Use the address lookup tool linked to find your state representative and senator and their contact information.