The economic tradeoffs of Colorado’s paid sick leave mandate

Posted

Paid sick leave provides workers with income security when illness prevents them from working. However, Colorado’s employer mandates to provide this benefit comes with economic tradeoffs that deserve greater consideration, particularly for small businesses. 

A look at paid sick leave

Research suggests that paid sick leave can reduce workplace illness, improve employee retention, and increase productivity. A study in the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health finds that employees without paid sick leave were more likely to work while sick, potentially spreading illness throughout the workplace.  

Mandates can also increase employer costs, creating potential challenges for firms. a 2009 Urban Institute study found that employers respond to paid sick leave mandates by adjusting existing benefits and compensation arrangements in order to afford what is required. Similarly, a study published by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) finds that mandates can encourage firms to offer additional benefits to remain competitive in the labor market. These adjustments can place smaller firms at a disadvantage as they have less financial flexibility for hiring, wages, and other benefits. 

Mandates can also affect businesses beyond those directly subject to the requirements. A study from the Journal of Policy Analysis and Management finds that employers with more locations affected by paid sick leave mandates are also more likely to offer paid sick leave at locations where it is not required. Therefore, mandates may motivate firms to locate in areas where there are less or no mandates at all, potentially harming local economies with mandates. Additionally, a study in the Pacific Economic Review finds that an increase in federal regulation disproportionately reduces small businesses’ shares of employment and output. These findings suggest that regulatory costs may discourage business expansion and investment in areas with more regulation. 

How is this relevant to Colorado?

These tradeoffs are particularly relevant in Colorado. As of 2025 small businesses account for 99.5% of all employers in the state, according to the Small Business Administration. 

Under Colorado’s Healthy Families and Workplaces Act, employees accrue one hour of paid sick leave for every 30 hours worked, up to 48 hours annually. Employers must account for these paid absences while continuing to meet their operational needs. For smaller businesses with limited staffing and financial flexibility, these additional costs may affect hiring, wages, and other employee benefits. 

The financial implications are rather substantial. Using 2025 Colorado occupational wage and employment data, an estimate based on 12 hours of paid sick leave per employee is approximately $1.28 billion in statewide wage payments. If employees use the full 48 hour annual allowance, that figure rises to approximately $5.12 billion. These estimates do not represent the potential savings from eliminating the mandate, but they illustrate the considerable amount of compensation allocated to required leave. 

The issue is not whether employees benefit from paid sick leave. They clearly do. Rather, it is whether requiring the same benefit across different industries, businesses, and workforces is the most effective way to provide it. 

Besides which, employees value compensation differently. Where some may prioritize paid time off, others may prefer things such as higher wages, flexible schedules, or alternative benefits. Allowing employers and employees greater flexibility to negotiate compensation packages could better accommodate these preferences while reducing unnecessary burdens on smaller businesses. 

Colorado should consider whether standardized mandates are the best way to improve employee well-being, or whether a more flexible labor market would better serve both workers and employers. 

Parker Palmer is from Boulder, and recently graduated  from the College of Charleston with a double major in Economics and History, and a double minor in International Studies and Data Science. She is planning to attend graduate school this fall to get a PhD in Economics. 

The post The economic tradeoffs of Colorado’s paid sick leave mandate appeared first on Complete Colorado.

Business/Economy, Exclusives, Health Care, Politics, Uncategorized, paid sick leave, Parker Palmer